He deduced that the victim had faked his own death.
Did Sherlock know, even then? Before Hounds? That sneaky little shit. Good Lord, John, how many clues has he actually left you?
I am an experienced medical doctor recently returned from Afghanistan. Feel free to ask me anything and I will answer to the very best of my abilities.
(Character Roleplay Tumblr. I am not associated with BBC's Sherlock in any way.)
Please see the following tumblrs of my friends and colleagues: